Verdict: Metaphor: ReFantazio is the best JRPG Atlus has made and one of the best role-playing games in years. It earns its length and then some.

Play it if you like: Persona 5, Final Fantasy XII, Dragon Quest XI, games that treat their worlds seriously.

Disclosure: This copy was purchased on PlayStation 5. No review code was provided.


Story

The kingdom of Euchronia is holding an election to replace its murdered king. Any citizen can run. The protagonist, a young traveller from a persecuted underclass, enters the race not because he believes he can win, but because the alternative is worse.

That setup sounds like a political fantasy novel and that is exactly what Metaphor: ReFantazio is. Director Katsura Hashino (Persona 3, 4, 5) has made something that takes its own premise seriously. The game asks what it means to lead, why people follow fear instead of hope, and what a just society actually requires. These are not themes it gestures at in cutscenes. They drive every mechanic.

Combat

The battle system combines the Press Turn mechanics of Shin Megami Tensei with real-time skirmishing borrowed from action games. Weak enemies can be eliminated before entering the turn-based phase if you strike them in the field. Dangerous enemies require the full tactical system. The two modes complement each other perfectly.

The archetype system – the game’s version of job classes – is deep without being overwhelming. By the midgame you are building team compositions that feel like your own solutions to specific challenges. By the endgame those solutions are being stress-tested in ways that feel fair.

Music

Shoji Meguro returns. The soundtrack is exceptional. That is not a surprise but it is worth saying plainly: the music is exceptional.

What does not quite land

The pacing in chapters 3 and 4 drags. The story is building toward something but the interim is slower than the opening act warrants. It recovers. But you will notice it.

Final score

9.5 / 10

The 0.5 is for the mid-game pacing. Everything else is operating at the highest level.